Voters cast their ballots in the Bronx on Saturday. The Board of Elections is under heightened scrutiny because this is the first presidential election with early voting in New York. Credit…Desiree Rios for The New York Times
The official who oversees voter registration in New York City is the 80-year-old mother of a former congressman. The director of Election Day operations is a close friend of Manhattan’s Republican chairwoman. The head of ballot management is the son of a former Brooklyn Democratic district leader. And the administrative manager is the wife of a City Council member.
As the workings of American democracy have become more complex — with sophisticated technology, early voting and the threat of foreign interference — New York has clung to a century-old system of local election administration that is one of the last vestiges of pure patronage in government, a relic from the era of powerful political clubhouses and Tammany Hall.
Now, the agency is facing perhaps its biggest challenge yet: a heated general election, during a pandemic, under a president who has fomented distrust in the legitimacy of the vote — including by pointing to the problems in New York as evidence of widespread fraud, an unfounded claim.
“I expect the B.O.E. to pull this off — there’s no other option. It’s the most important election of our lifetime,” said Scott Stringer, the city comptroller. “But we shouldn’t have to hold our breath because of their gross incompetence.”
“It is really hard to have co-workers who are incapable of performing what they need to do,” said Charles Stimson, a trainer assistant who has worked at the board on and off since 1992.
Mr. Stimson was one of more than a dozen current and former employees who told The Times that the agency has a culture where ineptitude is common and accountability is rare. Some staffers read or watch Netflix at the office, the employees said. Others regularly fail to show up for work, with no fear of discipline. Several employees said some staffers punch in and then leave to go shopping or to the gym.
Under board rules, almost every job must be duplicated, with a Republican and Democrat each performing the same function.
“The agency is chronically dysfunctional,” said Mr. Stimson, who said he has complained internally and to a city watchdog.
Betty Ann Canizio, a former clerk who was pushed out after the voter purge, said she caught workers smoking marijuana at the Brooklyn voting machine warehouse on an election night. She said she told two commissioners and the board’s executive director, none of whom took action.
As the June primary approached this year, the board — despite assuring the state it could handle a surge in residents seeking to vote by mail — grew so overwhelmed that it called two upstate companies for help printing absentee ballots on the weekend before the election, officials acknowledged.
Voters at Madison Square Garden on Saturday, the first day of early voting in New York. Tens of thousands of residents showed up to polling places. Credit…Desiree Rios for The New York Times.
It did not send the companies the names of voters who still needed ballots until late afternoon that Sunday, less than two days before the vote.
The companies worked through the night. But in all, 34,000 ballot packages were not mailed to voters until the day before the primary, and many likely did not arrive in time to be returned and counted. Ultimately, about one-fifth of primary ballots were thrown out for arriving late or other defects; in other states, the rate was 5 percent or less.
Last month, one of the printing companies sent general election packages to voters that had return envelopes with the wrong names. The mistake, which the company blamed on a mechanical error, affected a print run of 100,000 packages, although the company said fewer than 1,000 voters received flawed packages.
The Board of Elections blamed the vendor, but others called it a failure of oversight.
The ballots were already causing confusion because they were labeled “absentee military,” missing the slash that would indicate they could be used for either purpose.
Valerie Vazquez-Diaz, a board spokeswoman, acknowledged it had not checked the work of the vendor, Phoenix Graphics Inc. of Rochester, N.Y., which had been given a no-bid contract. Phoenix said it had printed millions of ballots without mistakes.
Ms. Vazquez-Diaz said the board struggled in the primary because of a 10-fold increase in requests for absentee ballots and because under state law, it had to honor requests postmarked up to a week before the election.
She added that the board has improved its processes since the primary, including by creating a system so voters can track their ballots online.
“The work we have accomplished is unprecedented and was performed under extraordinary circumstances,” she said in a statement. “Criticisms of boards of elections are readily made while the hard work and dedication of such boards are widely ignored.”
The structure of the city Board of Elections is enshrined in the state Constitution, and it has its defenders. Some believe that partisan appointees watching each other works better than concentrating control in one elected official, as many states do.
Government watchdogs say the board has a difficult mission and has made improvements over the years, such as digitizing voter registration records that had long been kept on millions of notebook-bound cards. A spokesman for the state Board of Elections said every local agency has struggled during the pandemic.
But the New York City board has come under consistent criticism for decades.
In 1940, a city investigation found it was plagued by “illegality, inefficiency, laxity and waste.” In 1971, a New York Times editorial derided it as “at best a semi‐functioning anachronism.” And in 1985, another city inquiry said it had an “almost embarrassing lack of understanding” of its job.
Still, state lawmakers have never seriously pushed to amend the state Constitution to create a professional structure. And the City Council has not used its power over approving commissioners to force change.
Elected officials are often quick to criticize the board but deflect responsibility. Representatives for Mr. de Blasio and City Council Speaker Corey Johnson noted the state controls the board’s structure. On Sunday, Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo, who has not lobbied state lawmakers to reform the board, said he believes the city should take the lead and bring a proposal to the state.
“They run it. They appoint the people. They set the rules,” Mr. Cuomo said.
Reform seemed inevitable after the city Department of Investigation released a scathing report in 2013. Investigators found “illegalities, misconduct, and antiquated operations,” including that nearly 10 percent of employees were related to another staffer.
Seven years later, little has changed, according to the current and former employees.
A core group of the political appointees are highly capable and keep the board running, but many others are unqualified, the employees said.
A voter at the Barclays Center in Brooklyn on Saturday. A printer sent erroneous general election ballot packages to many residents last month, creating confusion.Credit…Dave Sanders for The New York Times
“It’s nice to know that we’ve sometimes changed the lives of people,” he said.
The county party chairs choose the board’s 10 commissioners — one Democrat and one Republican from each borough — and most other board employees. Tradition dictates that when staffers leave, they are replaced by someone from the same party and borough.
Employees include Beth Fossella, the head of voter registration and mother of a former Republican congressman from Staten Island, Vito J. Fossella; Thomas Sattie, director of ballot management and son of the former Brooklyn Democratic district leader Maryrose Sattie; Pamela Perkins, administrative manager and wife of Democratic City Councilman Bill Perkins; Raphael Savino, deputy general counsel and brother of Joseph Savino, the former Bronx Republican leader; and Daniel Ortiz, deputy clerk in Brooklyn and son of Assemblyman Felix W. Ortiz, a Democrat.
Others have different connections. Debra Leible, head of Election Day operations, for example, is a longtime friend of Andrea Catsimatidis, the head of the Manhattan Republican Party.
“It’s like being in line at a concert,” said Chicava Roslyn Tate, who got hired through a former City Council member and worked at the board until the spring. “People just get swept in.”
The employees did not respond to requests for comment.
It is difficult to find skilled workers, current and former employees said, because many jobs involve tedious work and require late hours. Employees are also expected to attend fund-raising dinners and carry petitions for candidates favored by their parties. At the same time, it is hard to punish staffers, because commissioners control the disciplinary process and protect their own, employees said.
Mike Ryan, the executive director, was not disciplined by the agency after NY1 reported that he sat on the advisory board of a voting machine company that did business with the city and paid for his travel. (He was fined $2,500 by the Conflicts of Interest Board.) Jose Miguel Araujo, the Democratic commissioner from Queens, was reappointed in 2016 after he was fined $10,000 for giving his wife a job.
Problems at the board burst into public view during the voter purge in the 2016 Democratic presidential primary between Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders. Officials said they erred during a routine effort to remove people who had died or moved, but they later acknowledged violating the law.
Ms. Canizio, one of two clerks who were suspended for the purge and ultimately left, said she had no part in it and was scapegoated.
“My job was actually like babysitting,” said Ms. Canizio, who got the job after working for a member of the Assembly. “I felt like I was working in an insane asylum.”
In 2018, long lines followed the breakdown of scores of scanning machines. Mr. Ryan blamed the rainy weather, an explanation that drew ridicule.
The board’s recent miscues have renewed calls for reform. “Once we get through this election, I think we will have to have a very serious discussion,” said State Senator Zellnor Myrie, a Brooklyn Democrat who chairs the Elections Committee.
Another state senator, Liz Krueger of Manhattan, said her own experience with the board 20 years ago makes her wary.
Ms. Krueger, a Democrat, narrowly lost a 2000 State Senate race to Roy Goodman, the incumbent and a Republican Party leader with sway over the elections board. Months later, according to three people familiar with the incident, workers found hundreds of ballots in a Board of Elections air conditioning duct. The ballots were from a part of the district that had favored Ms. Krueger.
“Now in close races,” Ms. Krueger said, “I personally call up each side and say, ‘Check the ceiling tiles every night.’”
Dana Rubinstein, Jesse McKinley and Luis Ferré-Sadurní contributed reporting. Kitty Bennett and Susan C. Beachy contributed research.
Brian M. Rosenthal is an investigative reporter on the Metro Desk of The New York Times and the winner of the 2020 Pulitzer Prize in Investigative Reporting. @brianmrosenthal • Facebook
Michael Rothfeld is an investigative reporter on the Metro desk and co-author of the book “The Fixers.” He was part of a team at The Wall Street Journal that won the 2019 Pulitzer Prize for national reporting for stories about hush money deals made on behalf of Donald Trump and a federal investigation of the president’s personal lawyer. @mrothfeld